LETTER: Fayston rep shares school consolidation choice view

November 17, 2026 | By Karl Naden

To the Community:

On Wednesday, Nov. 18, the Harwood Unified Union School District School Board will vote on which school buildings to consider closing next year. This will not be a final decision, but it will set which buildings would close if approved by a two-thirds vote of the board on January 6. The district has posted the agenda for the meeting as well as an explanation of the process by which the board will formally decide which buildings to consider closing.

I have spent the past week listening and talking to people about the school board’s impending decision regarding school consolidation. The choice is not clear, but based on what I have heard and my own reflections and analysis, my current conclusion is that a Waitsfield-Warren configuration that closes the Fayston and Moretown buildings is the right next step for the district, preserving educational quality and advancing grade alignment across buildings, demonstrating the fiscal responsibility that we will need when we try to float a bond, and orienting our district towards the relative density of and new housing prospects in Waitsfield that represents what I see as our best hope of protecting our student enrollment numbers.

You can find my full analysis and current thinking in this document.

While this is my current conclusion, I am still listening, thinking, and weighing the options. In particular, I still wonder if the Moretown-Waitsfield configuration, which closes Fayston and Warren, should be made to work, as it better orients our district to the sources of jobs to the north. I welcome feedback and thoughts on other perspectives to consider and places where my rationale doesn’t line up. There is objective data in here, but combining it all into a cogent argument for a specific decision involves countless subjective choices about what data to consider and how heavily to weigh it.

I want to thank everyone who has engaged in the process and shared their perspectives and opinions. I look forward to continued discussions through Nov. 18 and I hope that afterwards we can pivot as a community towards building the four new schools borne out of this change: two valley preschool-4 schools, a unified 5-6 school at Crossett Brook, and a unified 7-8 middle school at Harwood.

Our decisions around consolidation will impact all students and families in this district, and the sooner that we can begin planning how to support students and families through this transition, including those disproportionately impacted by the changes, the better the outcome will be for everyone.

Karl Naden

Fayston

Naden is one of two Fayston members of the HUUSD School Board.

Previous
Previous

LETTER: Reps Torre and White to host housing discussion Dec. 2 in Warren

Next
Next

Op-Ed: Another view on school consolidation