LETTER: Education expert refutes school-closure wisdom

November 19, 2026

Editor’s Note: This letter sent to the HUUSD School Board is shared with the community as well.

To the Harwood School Board,

As the Harwood School Board makes decisions related to school closure, please note the following research.

Closing schools will not fix your financial problems – it will create damaging new ones. Research shows little to no correlation between cost and quality in relation to school size. While school closure of unsustainable schools may be necessary, and steps can be made to mitigate the impact, school board members should be aware of the consequences of school closure. School closure should be an act of last resort, and boards should take great care to follow a rigorous process that mitigates harm.

Recommendation:

The first question to ask is: Are the Harwood elementary schools unsustainable due to enrollment decline? Schools that can meet minimum class sizes with multi-age classes are not unsustainable. They should be preserved as community schools because everyone agrees young children should go to school close to home.

School closure should be approached with clearly articulated due-process requirements. A town vote on school closure is an essential element to ensure due process is attained. It will demonstrate that the planning process has resulted in comprehensive plans and mitigates avoidable consequences. Vermonters need assurances that their children will not face long bus rides and that there are plans in place for public buildings in their communities; given such evidence, the historical record shows Vermonters will vote to close unsustainable schools.

Closing schools is damaging to children. 

Studies of school closures show that students:

  • Experience a loss of connectedness with peers and their community.

  • Face increased mental health challenges.

  • In the short term, have lower test scores, worse attendance, and behavioral issues. 

  • Face negative impacts from declining family and community engagement.

  • Absenteeism is increased, as is homeschooling

Closing schools does not save money. 

Children from closed schools need an education. National research shows that per-pupil spending tends to increase post-closure, while anticipated cost efficiencies from “economies of scale” rarely materialize. Transportation costs increase, wider opportunities promised cost money, and empty public buildings need to be maintained. School closures tend to result in the redistribution of money away from the direct education of students rather than financial savings.

Closing schools impacts equity. 

Research finds that students experiencing poverty, students of color, and those with special needs are most negatively impacted by school closures. Without accessible community schools’ rural children are disadvantaged, 

Closing schools negatively impacts communities. 

In communities where schools are closed, research points to depopulation, declining home values, eroding social capital, and problems with attracting and retaining families with children. 

Closing schools without due process has consequences. 

Only an inclusive, open-minded analysis of the pros and cons of closure results in a decision that is supported by the majority of voters. Sufficient time to clarify a path forward and plan for the future can avoid some unintended consequences. Examples include excessively long bus rides and abandoned school buildings with no clear educational plan for their re-use. 

Decisions to close schools should not be made due to the pressure of budget constraints. It is the responsibility of the state to resolve the funding formula for education. Meanwhile, your whole system needs to address budget issues across the board rather than the pain be heaped on specific young children and their communities.

Margaret MacLean

Peacham

Educator, teacher, principal, national consultant for the Rural School Community Trust, State Board of Education member, steering committee member with Rural School Community Alliance.


More information:  

Previous
Previous

Op-Ed: A great education injustice in the Mad River Valley

Next
Next

LETTER: Rotary holiday ‘tree’ to be lit Nov. 27