November 19, 2026 | By Peter LangellaImagine a school in rural Vermont that is bucking trends and narratives at every turn. Its enrollment is growing. Families from other towns use intradistrict choice to attend. The school offers an award-winning Educating Children Outdoors program across its 170 acres of fields, forests, and trails, where every teacher has a dedicated nature classroom in the trees.
Now imagine that school is slated for closure.
I’m talking about Moretown Elementary, my exceptional community school.
The Harwood Unified Union School District’s own numbers show that district enrollment declined 18% between 2009–10 and 2025–26. Warren Elementary declined 37.2%. Waitsfield Elementary declined 23.4%. Fayston Elementary declined 18.8%. Brookside Primary declined 16.9%.
Moretown grew by 14.2% from 120 kindergarten–6th grade students to 137! When preschoolers are included, Moretown had 178 students last year.
Something happened here.
Maybe it’s the ECO program and the outdoor spaces. Maybe it's years of onsite childcare and after-school programming. Maybe it's housing affordability relative to neighboring towns, or young families arriving at the right time. Probably it's all of those things and more.
But instead of studying and trying to model the exceptional outlier, the HUUSD School Board has voted to move Moretown (and Fayston) toward closure.
Representatives from other towns can, under the district’s Articles of Agreement, vote to close Moretown’s public school even when the people of Moretown are begging them not to.
That may be legal.
But it is not just.
The process that got us here didn’t begin with a careful educational inquiry into what would be best for children. It began with a financial crisis created in part by decisions in Montpelier. Act 169 lowered Vermont’s excess-spending threshold and put enormous pressure on districts like ours to make rapid structural cuts. HUUSD is not alone. Other districts are facing millions in reductions, school closures, and major reconfigurations.
Even the HUUSD superintendent has said the process feels backward – Vermont tightened the financial screws before the new educational structure was actually in place.
The Scott administration and Democrat-controlled Legislature have both failed communities like ours, and the HUUSD has responded by creating its own false binary. For months, we were told the choices were essentially this: maintain the “status quo” and devastate programs to stay under the excess spending threshold, or close schools and consolidate children.
Community members proposed alternatives, but those ideas were never given the same financial analysis or administrative attention devoted to closures, and the board never investigated what a closure like this may mean for our town.
Now, Moretown may lose its heart.
I do not say that lightly.
Research on rural school closures shows that schools are part of the social and economic infrastructure of small communities. Studies have linked closures to population decline, reduced home values, weaker community participation, longer travel times, and loss of social connection. The harms are not abstract. They show up in whether young families stay, whether people move in, whether children can participate after school, and whether a town still feels like a place organized around a shared community fabric.
The powerbrokers in Montpelier say that they want Moretowns all over the state while simultaneously enacting laws and policies that make it almost impossible. They may say we’re an anomalous unintended consequence, but impact is greater than intention every single time.
And then, most importantly, there are the children.
Children who now walk into a school where adults know them and know their families will be redistributed elsewhere. Some will spend much more time traveling on buses. I worry most about the children with IEPs and those experiencing generational rural poverty; children whose success depends on trusted adults, predictable routines, and strong relationships.
Consolidated buildings do not automatically create better opportunities for those children. Research consistently shows that young people who experience a school closure face increased mental health challenges, worse attendance, lower short-term academic achievement, declining family and community engagement, higher homeschooling rates, and a loss of community and peer connection.
Vermont has long treated public schools as the epicenters of its towns. Our governance structures have changed, and unified districts now hold powers individual communities once held. But I still cannot believe that Vermont’s version of democracy is supposed to end with neighbors voting to take away their neighbors’ public school while the people who live there plead with them not to.
There is a great education injustice happening in the Mad River Valley, and if a thriving, growing Moretown Elementary can be slated for closure, I worry a great deal about the future of public education in this state.
Moretown resident Peter Langella is an educator and former member of the Harwood Unified Union School District School Board.